• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

GILL Solutions

Growing your business..Should be Strategic!

  • Our Process
  • Services
    • Full Service
      • Search Engine Optimization Service
      • Conversion Optimization
      • PPC Advertising Management
      • Social Media Marketing Service
      • Full Stack Development
    • Google Analytics Audit
    • Marketing Coach
    • Domains & Hosting
  • Training
    • Marketing Certification
      • Conversion Optimization Certification
      • Digital Advertising Certification
      • Search Engine Optimization Certification
      • Marketing Automation Certification
      • Content Marketing Certification
      • Social Media Strategy and Deployment Certification
    • Google Analytics Training
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Contact Us
  • Call 1-877-801-4090

Jun 12 2008

Search Intent, Analytics and the Multi-Competent Web

Long before I started working in SEO I was an educator for an organization that taught computer skills to total neophytes. You learn a lot from working with completely fresh users. It makes you realize how much of your ability comes from deeply ingrained basic assumptions and how these can work for or against you.

By far, the greatest conceptual barrier for new computer users is that they see conscious, dynamic reactions in automated processes. It takes practice for them to learn that Google only responds to their input, not the intentions behind it. Search engines behave like they understand text. If you’re not computer literate, the first connection you make to that behavior is a conscious intent, because the only other things in your experience that exhibit it are other human beings.

Now at this point, I’m sure a lot of you are feeling very superior to these “n00bs,” but the fact is, a lot of you may be making the same kind of mistake when you analyze search traffic. You’re a search pro, so the tendency is to assume that even if people aren’t search pros, they’re approaching Google with a basic search skills – but they aren’t. There’s more to it than assuming people won’t use quotes or other inline commands.

The modern web is multi-competent. I think this insight is so important that I had to make up a word, so bear with me. Multi-competence doesn’t just mean that searchers don’t all have the same web literacy, but that web literacy doesn’t always say anything about other skills. There are ignorant master searchers and IT pros who can’t find anything.

In practical terms, this means we have to question our assumptions when we check analytics. Sometimes we have to get really basic and go back to the core of the search experience. For instance, this article discusses “navigational searches,” where people enter full URLs into search bars. Why do people do it? To find out, do the following:

  1. Go to Google
  2. Type in a URL

Where does the URL appear? If you followed my steps exactly, it appears in the search bar. If you’re search literate, you might have ignored my instructions by reflexively clicking in the address bar – but many searchers do not have this reflex! They’re not necessarily aware of the cursor’s location or for that matter, the difference between search and URL fields. Search engines as default home pages and address bars defaulting to searches create even more confusion. Teaching the differences was one of the hardest parts of my old job.

Thanks to multi-competence, you can’t tell this is a search skills issue by examining keywords for “dumbness.” Lots of smart people have bad search skills. So based on my hands on experience with new searchers, I’m pretty confident that it boils down to how the basic, home page search interface works. There probably isn’t any hidden service demand behind navigational searches – there are just guys typing, pressing Enter, and living with whatever comes up.

This is just one example of how competence differences can confuse your analysis. Here are some more:

  1. New searchers often believe they must add the .com TLD suffix to the end of their search term, even if they aren’t looking for a URL.
  2. Much of the time, they also think they must omit spaces from searches, because they were told to omit them from URLs and don’t know the difference between a keyword and URL.
  3. New searchers don’t necessarily know it is even possible to go directly to a URL. They’re used to word searches or mistyping domains, so when the address bar defaults to a search page, they believe that this is how it’s supposed to work, all the time.
  4. They may add their country code to a search or address, instead of the TLD suffix of where they actually want to go.

[ad name=”Post-Banner”]

Written by malcolm · Categorized: Marketing · Tagged: search engine marketing

About malcolm

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Adam says

    June 13, 2008 at 7:32 am

    Hey Malcolm,
    Good observation.
    This makes perfect sense when you think of homepages. I tell my mom to open a browser and go to gill-media.com.

    She opens it and starts typing, never clicking on the address bar. This performs a keyword search.

  2. GILL_Media says

    October 23, 2009 at 1:20 pm

    Like this article: SEO & Searcher Mental Models http://bit.ly/wDnJm We did a peice on a related them in 08 at http://bit.ly/1BT2PH

Primary Sidebar

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive email updates weekly and to hear what’s going on with us!

Business Strategy

GILL Solutions Management Is an Industry Game Changer in Canada

March 9, 2022 By George Gill

GILL Solutions Management takes pride in its ability to deliver world-class digital solutions for reasonable costs. We’re an experienced team that works with businesses in identifying the most optimal ways to … Continue Reading about GILL Solutions Management Is an Industry Game Changer in Canada

Important Benefits of Facebook for Your Business

May 15, 2020 By George Gill

Whether you are a person who likes social media or not, if you're in business, there is a good chance that at some point you've considered FaceBook for your business. Understanding what the benefits are, is an … Continue Reading about Important Benefits of Facebook for Your Business

Before You Start – Is Social Media Marketing Profitable

May 14, 2020 By George Gill

We all know Social Media is popular. But before your business goes down the path of investing resources and budget into this marketing channel, you need to know what to expect. Most importantly can it be profitable … Continue Reading about Before You Start – Is Social Media Marketing Profitable

Do You Have to Pay for Search Engine Optimization

May 12, 2020 By George Gill

Every business I have ever spoken to has unanimously agreed, they would love to be on page one of Google for the keywords directly related to their business. Most believe they deserve to be at the top, and the … Continue Reading about Do You Have to Pay for Search Engine Optimization

How Important is Conversion Optimization to Your Business

May 11, 2020 By George Gill

With over 20 years in the digital marketing field, the number one approach to quickly generate the greatest impact on a business's results that I've witnessed has been accomplished through conversion rate … Continue Reading about How Important is Conversion Optimization to Your Business

Why is Siteground so expensive vs competitors

Why is Siteground so Expensive vs Competitors

May 7, 2020 By George Gill

Hosting your website is a very big deal for many reasons that we'll discuss in this article. Siteground is a hosting company (click to see Siteground's current offer) we often recommend, even though they tend to be … Continue Reading about Why is Siteground so Expensive vs Competitors

Footer

GILL Solutions Management
7901 4th St. N STE 4155
St. Petersburg, FL 33702

GILL Solutions Management
3080 Yonge Street, Suite 6060
Toronto, Ontario M4N-3N1

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

GILL Solutions Management
P.O. Box 30024 RPO Chemong
Peterborough, Ontario, K9H 7R4

  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Our Blog
  • Student Login
  • Contact Us

©2020 GILL Solutions Management LLC